From Friday Deep-Dive · Friday, October 2, 2026 · 8 min read
The website stops being the destination and becomes the source
For twenty years the deal was simple: publish, get found, sell the visit. That deal is coming apart, and the measurements are not subtle. Pew found that an AI summary at the top of Google cuts clicks on regular results roughly in half. Cloudflare reports most requests for web content now come from machines rather than people, and the AI crawlers take thousands of pages for every visitor they send back. But the fashionable conclusion, that your website no longer matters, is exactly backwards for a publication. Your site is what the answers are made of. In the full post: which claims hold up and which do not, five concrete things to do on your own site, a prompt that shows you what AI tools say about your publication today, and the new rate card sitting inside all of this for your ad department.
A video has been going around aimed at local business owners. The pitch: your website will not matter in a couple of years, so pour everything into social media and reviews.
A friend sent it to me asking if it was true.
Parts of it are true, and the data behind those parts is worse than the video says. Other parts are flat wrong, and one piece of its advice would cost a small operation real money. And almost none of it was written with a publication in mind, which is where it gets interesting, because the picture for us is genuinely different.
Here is the honest version.
What is actually true
Search sends fewer people than it used to. This is not a feeling, it is measured.
- The Pew Research Center watched about 69,000 real searches. When Google showed an AI summary at the top, people clicked a regular result 8 percent of the time. With no AI summary, 15 percent. Roughly half the clicks, gone. And people clicked a link inside the summary itself about 1 percent of the time.
- Press Gazette reported that Google traffic to publishers worldwide fell by about a third during 2025, with United States sites hit harder than that.
- Similarweb measured news site traffic down about 26 percent in the year after AI Overviews arrived.
- Cloudflare now reports that most requests hitting web content come from machines, not people. Their crawl-to-referral numbers bounce around by company and by month, but the shape holds everywhere: AI crawlers take thousands of pages for every single visitor they send back.
So yes. The road that used to bring people to your front door is narrowing, and it is narrowing fast.
What the video got wrong
Three things, and they matter because acting on them costs money.
"Nobody searches anymore." Google still handles around 90 percent of searches, and total search volume is still growing, not shrinking. ChatGPT is genuinely enormous now, roughly 900 million people a week, and it has taken a real bite. But it mostly added a new habit rather than replacing the old one. Plan for both. Abandoning search because a video told you it is over would be a mistake.
"Organic results are all on page two now." Google labels its ads "Sponsored." They are not disguised as regular results. What is true is subtler and worse: there are more ads up top, the label is small, ads now look like everything else on the page, and above all of it sits an AI answer that often means nobody scrolls at all. The problem is not hidden ads. It is the answer that removes the reason to click.
"Your website will not matter." For a plumber, there is an argument. For a publication, this is backwards. Your site is the thing the AI answers are built out of. Those crawlers in the Cloudflare numbers are coming to you. Take your site away and you do not escape the machine, you just disappear from what it tells people.
The actual change
Your website is not dying. Its job is changing.
For twenty years it was a destination. You made a thing, Google sent strangers to it, the strangers saw ads.
Now it is two different things:
- The source of record that answer engines read, quote, and cite. You will not always get the click. You will increasingly get the credit, the name, and the authority.
- The home of the audience you actually own, the people who come directly because it is your publication, not because an algorithm pointed at you this morning.
Those are two different jobs, and they need two different kinds of work.
What to do on your own site
1 Decide your bot policy on purpose.
Right now the bots are making this decision for you. Two kinds are hitting your site: training crawlers that copy your work to build models and send you nothing, and answer crawlers that fetch a page so a chatbot can quote it, usually with a link back.
Most publications want to block the first and allow the second. Blocking everything feels satisfying and takes you out of the AI answers your readers are already using.
If your site runs through Cloudflare, it now gives you separate free switches for search bots, training bots, and agent bots. If it does not, this is a conversation with whoever hosts your site. Either way, decide it deliberately this month.
2 Make your pages easy for a machine to read.
Not tricks. Plumbing.
- Answer first. Put the who, what, and when in the first two sentences, not in paragraph six. A machine pulling a quote grabs the top.
- Real text, not pictures of text. A meeting story trapped in a PDF or a graphic cannot be quoted by anything.
- Dates and bylines on every story, clearly marked. Recency and authorship are how a machine decides whether to trust a page.
- Add Article schema if your site can. It is a small block of code that labels a page as a news story with a headline, author, and date. Google recommends structured data, and it is the one technical step with real evidence behind it. Ask your website provider whether you already have it. Most modern platforms do.
- Skip llms.txt. It gets talked about constantly. Ahrefs checked about 137,000 sites and found that 97 percent of the llms.txt files out there were never requested by any AI bot at all. Do not spend money on it yet.
3 Publish the things a summary cannot replace.
An AI can summarize your council story. It cannot generate the things only you have.
Obituaries. Local photographs. Game results with real names. The full text of the budget document nobody else posted. Court and property records. The events calendar that is actually correct. School lunch menus, if we are being honest about what gets read.
That material is unsummarizable because it does not exist anywhere else. It is also exactly what makes you the source an answer engine has to cite.
4 Own a channel nobody can change the rules on.
Google changed the rules. So did Facebook, twice. The channels you own outright are your print edition, your email list, your app, and your text alerts.
One number worth pulling this week: what share of your traffic arrives direct or from email versus from search and social. If that first number is growing, you are building something durable, whatever happens to search. If it is shrinking, that is the problem to work on, and it matters more than your ranking.
5 Find out what the machines currently say about you.
Takes five minutes and most publishers have never done it.
I am checking how AI tools describe a local publication.
1. What is the main local news source for [your town, your state]? Name the publications you know of.
2. Who publishes [your publication's name] and what area does it cover?
3. What happened at the most recent [your town] city council meeting?
4. Where would you tell someone to go for local obituaries in [your town]?
For each answer, list the websites you used, and tell me plainly when you do not know something rather than guessing.
Run it in ChatGPT, then run it again in Google's AI mode. You are looking for three things: whether you are named at all, whether the facts about you are right, and whose website it cites when it answers a question you should own. If it is citing a regional paper sixty miles away for your town's news, that is the gap to close.
Now the part with money in it
Everything above is defense. Here is the offense, and I think it is the real story for a publication.
Every advertiser you have is about to get this same bad news, and almost none of them know what to do about it. The video going around is a symptom: local businesses are being told their website is worthless, and they are frightened and shopping for answers.
You already sell them marketing. This is a rate card.
Listings accuracy. AI tools decide whether to recommend a business partly on whether its name, address, and phone number match everywhere they appear. Most small businesses have three different phone numbers floating around the internet and old hours from before they moved. Cleaning that up is a concrete service with a concrete price, and you can do it for a whole block of Main Street.
Google Business Profile and reviews. Still the biggest lever in local, and the video got this part right. Most of your advertisers have a half-filled profile they have not touched since they claimed it.
ChatGPT ads. This is new and most local shops have not heard it yet. OpenAI started running ads in ChatGPT in February, and in May it opened a self-serve Ads Manager with cost-per-click bidding and no minimum spend, so a business can buy them the way it buys Google Ads. By August, OpenAI's ad business was reported at a billion dollars a year and climbing. Your ad reps can learn this before your market's other sellers do, and be the one who already knows how it works.
An AI visibility check. Run the prompt from Step 5 against an advertiser's business instead of your publication. Show them what ChatGPT says about them today. For a lot of owners, seeing the wrong phone number read back to them is the whole sale.
One honest limit, and say it out loud when you sell this. Nobody can guarantee a spot in an AI answer. There is no ranking to buy and no dial to turn. What you can promise is that the information out there about them is correct, complete, and consistent, which is what these systems actually reward. Any competitor promising the number one spot in ChatGPT is selling something they cannot deliver, and saying so plainly makes you the trustworthy one in the room.
What I would do first
Pick the two cheapest things on this list.
Run the Step 5 prompt on your own publication this week. Then run it on your three biggest advertisers and bring them what you find. One of those conversations turns into a sale, and it will be the easiest sale your rep makes this month, because you are not pitching, you are showing them something true about their own business that they did not know.
The website is not going away. It is turning into the place your work lives so machines can find it and your actual readers can come home to it. Those are both worth keeping.
Have a good weekend.
Try this and tell me what happened.
Did it work? Hit reply. Did it come back sounding like a stranger? Hit reply harder. That’s the interesting failure, and it’s almost always fixable.
Get the next one in your inbox
Tuesday brief + Friday deep-dive. Free. Unsubscribe anytime.
Subscribe — free, twice weekly